Sullivan County Criminal Court

Sullivan County Criminal Court handles all criminal cases that are filed in Sullivan County. See below for more information about criminal cases in Sullivan County.

Mandatory Appearances in Sullivan County Criminal Court

At a mandatory or required court appearance in Sullivan County, the defendant must appear before the court. In the event of a “Failure to Appear” the judge may issue a warrant for the arrest of the defendant. Note: not all criminal hearings are mandatory, in a non-mandatory hearing an attorney may appear on your behalf without you being in court.

Where can I get help for my Sullivan County criminal case?

The 6th amendment of the United States Constitution provides a criminal defendant with the right to an attorney. As read in the miranda rights, this means that if a defendant cannot afford to hire a private attorney a legal attorney will be appointed to the defendant to represent him at no cost to the defendant. This is often a public defender. In addition, the court clerk for Sullivan County will also be able to provide general information about a specific criminal case. The clerk can only provide information and is not an attorney so they cannot provide legal advice, only a licensed attorney can provide legal advice about what the best options for are for your particular case.

Sullivan County Criminal Court

Sullivan County Criminal Court

Burden of Proof Requirement

In a criminal case in the United States, the burden of proof always requires the prosecutor to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant is guilty. This is a high threshold that must be met by the prosecution when presenting evidence in a case. If the prosecution fails in it’s burden to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt the judge must find the defendant not guilty. In a jury trial, the judge will inform the jury what this burden is and their obligation to find the defendant not guilty if they feel the prosecution did prove the defendant’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

Appealing a Criminal Conviciton

A defendant may appeal a criminal conviction to an appellate court. In an appeal, the actual trial is not redone, but the appellate court hears arguments that the criminal case was not handled in a legal manner at the original criminal court. The appellate court can either uphold the conviction, or determine that errors were made and may request a retrial, a resentencing of the defendant or that the charges be dismissed.

Right to an attorney

The US Constitution’s Sixth Amendment ensures the right to an attorney regardless of whether or not you can afford one. In Sullivan County a public defender will be appointed by the judge if you cannot afford private representation.

Who is the prosecutor for Sullivan County?

Depending upon the case, the prosecutor for Sullivan County criminal cases will either be a representative of Sullivan County or a representative from New York. After reviewing evidence it is the prosecutor’s decision whether to file charges or drop a case. Most prosecutors have the ability to negotiate plea bargains, and determine how the case will be prosecuted.

What is Jury Deliberation?

After both the prosecution and defense have presented their cases, the judge in the case will provide instructions to the jury about what they must decide. The jury will be dismissed to the jury room where they will deliberate about the guilt or innocence of the defendant. After reaching a unaminous decision, they return their decision to the court where it is read aloud in the courtroom. If the jury is unable to reach a unaminous decision, the jury is deadlocked, also known as a hung jury, in which a mistrial will be declared.

Sullivan County Criminal Court locations

Criminal proceedings take place in the Sullivan County Criminal Courts. A list of the criminal courts are located here.

If guilty, who sentences the defendant?

If the defendant is found guilty after the trial, the defendent will be sentenced. In some cases, this can occur at the same hearing the defendant is found guilty in court, in other cases a separate hearing will be required. Often the prosecution will request a particular sentence for the defendant and the judge will determine whether to enforce this sentence or impose a different sentence for the defendant.

What happens in Sullivan County at an arraignment?

In Sullivan County the defendant is brought into court and informed by the judge of the charges that have been filed against them along with informing them of their rights. At this time, the defendant can plead guilty, not guilty or no contest. If the defendant pleads guilty or no contest, there will be no trial and the defendant may be sentenced immediately or at a later date. If the defendant pleads not guilty a trial date is set.

What is a Plea Agreement?

A plea agreement is a deal made between the prosecution and the defendant in a case, where the defendant agrees to plea guilty to a particular charge in exchange for some concession from the prosecutor. In practice, more than 90% of criminal cases end with a plea agreement.

Right to Jury Trial

For “Serious Crimes”, those that can have a potential penalty of 6 months in jail OR a minimum $500 penalty, the US Constitution guarantees a right to trial by jury. This is guaranteed by Article III of the Constitution and the 6th Amendment. The accused has the ability to waive their right to trial by jury.

Sullivan County Criminal Court Locations

  • Sullivan County Surrogate’s Court

    Address: 100 North Street, Monticello NY 12701
    Phone: 845-807-0690 Fax: 845-794-0310

  • Sullivan County Court

    Address: 414 Broadway, Monticello NY 12701
    Phone: 845-794-4066 Fax: 845-791-6170

  • Bethel Justice Court

    Address: Mailing: PO Box 691, Kauneonga Lake NY 12749
    Phone: 845-583-7420 Fax: 845-583-7804

  • Bloomingburg Village Court

    Address: 13 North Road, PO Box 314, Bloomingburg NY 12721
    Phone: 845-733-1400

  • Callicoon Town Court

    Address: 19 Legion Street, PO Box 687, Jeffersonville NY 12748
    Phone: 845-482-5390 Ext. 301 Fax: 845-482-9017

  • Cochecton Town Court

    Address: 74 Smales Road, Lake Huntington NY 12752
    Phone: 845-932-8360 Ext. 20

  • Delaware Town Court

    Address: 104 Main Street, PO Box 129, Hortonville NY 12745
    Phone: 845-887-5250 Ext. 8

  • Fallsburg Justice Court

    Address: 19 Railroad Plaza, PO Box 2019, South Fallsburg NY 12779
    Phone: 845-434-4574 Fax: 845-436-4372

  • Forestburgh Justice Court

    Address: 332 King Road, PO Box 114, Forestburgh NY 12777
    Phone: 845-794-0611 Ext. 29 Fax: 845-794-7855

  • Fremont Town Court

    Address: PO Box 69, Fremont Center NY 12736
    Phone: 607-498-4578

  • Highland Town Justice Court

    Address: 2 Schoolhouse Road, PO Box 207, Barryville NY 12719
    Phone: 845-557-8132 Fax: 845-557-0509

  • Liberty Town Court

    Address: 120 North Main Street, Liberty NY 12754
    Phone: 845-292-6980

  • Liberty Village Justice Court

    Address: 120 North Main Street, Liberty NY 12754
    Phone: 845-292-6980

  • Lumberland Justice Court

    Address: 1054 Proctor Road, PO Box 226, Glen Spey NY 12737
    Phone: 845-856-8600 Ext. 219

  • Mamakating Justice Court

    Address: 2948 Route 209, Wurtsboro NY 12790
    Phone: 845-888-3038

  • Monticello Village Court

    Address: 18 Pleasant Street, Monticello NY 12701
    Phone: 845-794-1222

  • Neversink Justice Court

    Address: 273 Main Street, PO Box 307, Grahamsville NY 12740
    Phone: 845-985-2262 Ext. 311 Fax: 845-985-7686

  • Rockland Justice Court

    Address: 1939 Old Route 17, PO Box 28, Roscoe NY 12776
    Phone: 607-498-4320 Fax: 607-498-6191

  • Thompson Town Court

    Address: 4052 Route 42, Monticello NY 12701
    Phone: 845- 794-7130

  • Tusten Justice Court

    Address: 210 Bridge Street, PO Box 195, Narrowsburg NY 12764
    Phone: 845-252-7146 Ext. 5

  • Woodridge Village Court

    Address: 2 Dairyland Road, PO Box 655, Woodridge NY 12789
    Phone: 845-434-3474

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.